Key takeaways
- Expect a small panel that asks every candidate the same questions and scores the answers against set criteria.
- Prepare five or six real stories from your work and tell them using STAR.
- Say "I", not "we". The panel can only score what you did yourself.
- Have your references ready before the interview.
Public service interviews feel more formal than a typical job interview, and that's on purpose. They are designed so every candidate is judged the same way. That's good news for you, because it means you can prepare for them.
What to expect
You'll usually face a panel of two to four people: often the hiring manager, someone from HR and a subject-matter expert. The interview might be in person, by phone or over video (BC often uses MS Teams).
Every candidate gets the same questions, and the panel scores each answer against expected responses it agreed on in advance. Ontario, BC and Saskatchewan all describe it this way. In practice, the panel is listening for specific points in your answer. If you don't say something, they can't give you credit for it, even if they suspect you know it.
The three kinds of questions
- Knowledge: what you know about the relevant laws, policies, procedures or systems. Read up on the department's programs and any legislation named in the posting.
- Situational: "What would you do if..." Walk through your thinking step by step.
- Behavioural: "Tell us about a time when..." These ask about something real you did in the past, and they are where most candidates lose points.
Answer with STAR
BC, Alberta and Winnipeg all recommend STAR for behavioural questions:
- Situation: set the scene briefly.
- Task: what you were responsible for.
- Action: what you did. This should be the longest part.
- Result: what happened, ideally with a number, and what you learned.
Ontario uses a shorter version called PAR (Problem, Action, Result). It works the same way, so use whichever label you like.
An example
This is a made-up example to show the structure. Use your own real stories.
Question: Tell us about a time you improved a process.
Situation: "My team tracked client requests in a shared spreadsheet, and some got missed at month end."
Task: "My manager asked me to fix it."
Action: "I talked to three colleagues to find out where requests were slipping through. Then I built a simple intake form with automatic reminders, wrote a one-page guide and ran a 20-minute walkthrough for the team."
Result: "Within two months we had no missed requests, and our average response time went from five days to two. I learned to involve the people who use a process before I change it."
Notice what makes this work: "I", specific actions, and numbers.
Before the interview
- Re-read the posting. Each essential qualification will probably turn into a question. Write down which of your stories covers each one.
- Research the department. Know what it does, its current priorities and its values.
- Prepare five or six stories you can adapt to different questions: a challenge, a conflict, a mistake, a process you improved, a time you worked with stakeholders, a time you were under deadline pressure.
- Practise out loud and time yourself. In a one-hour interview, BC suggests planning for 10 to 15 minutes per question. Answers that wander lose points.
- Line up references. About three, including a supervisor, and let them know a call may be coming.
- Ask for accommodations if you need them. Employers provide them.
During the interview
- Listen to the whole question. Some questions have two parts, so answer both.
- Don't assume the panel knows your workplace. Explain the context and spell out acronyms.
- It's fine to pause and think, or to ask the panel to repeat a question.
- Ask whether you can take notes, since some panels let you jot down questions.
- Keep it to your own contribution. "We did" answers are hard to score.
After the interview
Ask about next steps and timing before you leave. Reference checks usually come last, and in BC one reference has to be a supervisor or someone at a similar level. If you don't want your current boss contacted until there's an offer, say so. Hiring managers are used to that request.
If you don't get the job, ask for feedback. Alberta invites you to contact the HR person named in the posting. In New Brunswick you can request feedback within 30 days of the job being filled. Feedback is the fastest way to do better in the next competition, and there will be one.
Common mistakes
- Describing what you would do when the question asks what you did.
- Saying "we" for the whole answer.
- Long, unstructured stories with no clear result.
- Assuming the panel knows your background or reads between the lines.
- Not preparing for the knowledge questions about the department's work.
This is general information only. Always check the employer's own posting and HR pages for how its interviews work.